Pseudo experts and n00bs

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rodger

Banned
Feb 17, 2007
49
0
0
Every webmaster forum has pseudo experts and while they tend to be well-respected members of their communities they shoudn't be immune to criticism.

A pseudo expert is someone who posts guides and blogs regarding various internet marketing/SEO topics while making little if any money or success in the aforementioned fields. For example, a pseudo expert may write an ellaborate 2000 word guide on adult markerting that gets a positive reception, yet the original poster makes very little if any money on adult marketing. Another example would be someone who runs an SEO blog but doesn't make any money with SEO.

Since pseudo experts are uanable to make money online easily though automation (SEO, clickbank, azoogle etc) they tend to do a lot of tedious grunt work instead, usually for less than minimum wage. Such tasks include content writing, banner/logo design, directory submission, website design, wordpress installation, etc. If they were truley experts they woudn't have to perform grunt work but would be able to make automated income thorugh affiliate marketing or adsense.

In addition, pseudo experts tend to create so called 'marketing blogs' where they ramble about internet marketing and various widgets. The only problem is that they lack the skillset to establish any meaningful reader base or monitization.

Pseudo experts also make a lot of faulty assumptions in their writings. Eli, for example, whom I respect his efforts is a pseudo expert and he reveals that by making this noobish post regarding a so called free amazon.com link.
Blue Hat SEO-Advanced SEO Tactics » Free Amazon.com Link. While it is obvious that astore.amazon.com is an authority site it doesn't pass any of its link authority to the individual anazon stores. It is no different than having a blogger blog or a myspace account. True myspace and blogger are very well trusted domains, but they don't pass any authority to thier subpages which are actually orphan pages.

Pseudo experts aren't bad people; they are noobs though. And there is nothing with being a noob. But just don't pass yourself off as someone with expertise when you are unable to apply it to yourself.
 


yes, in life there are people who know shit, think they know shit, say that know shit. bottom line, they may or may not know shit.

reader beware.

did this really need a post?
 
yes, in life there are people who know shit, think they know shit, say that know shit. bottom line, they may or may not know shit.

reader beware.

did this really need a post?

That is true, but they shoudn't be immune to some degree of criticism being that they are noobs.
 
So that would make you a psuedo dildo right?

What's the point man? Are you gonna now sell a psuedo e-book?

And who are you to even place Eli in this post :error: when he has helped more people then a lot of peeps? Wait till the mods and guides come and rip you a new ass for that. :xomunch: I would have used like shoemoney or john chow but Eli?:error: :error: :error: :error: :error: :error:
 
you realize eli made like 25K off of his tool? and will proceed to make around that much every month as long as the spaces are filled.

You are talking out of your ass dude and just trying to start some flamebait. I agree that there are far too many people who talk a lot of shit when they don''t know what they're doing (me, for example) but when you call out people who actually do know what they're doing, then you just make yourself look stupid.
 
I have nothing against the guy but he along the owner of robstool pulled in 25,000 in a day...not through any actual form of SEO or blackhat but by selling a tool that is marketed to do blackhat. That along with neumerous erroneus statements in his blogging make him a pseudo expert. Sorry, but I call it as I see it. Free speech.

A pseudo expert isn't usually cocky; he is just wrong a lot of the time and either doesn't realize it or no one will tell him that he is wrong.
 
Rodger, are you kidding me? Do you really think Eli is a noob? Can you even replicate 10% of what he describes on his blogs? Instead of coming in here pointing fingers, why don't you contribute something here of value. Until then you are considered a fag.
 
you realize eli made like 25K off of his tool? and will proceed to make around that much every month as long as the spaces are filled.

You are talking out of your ass dude and just trying to start some flamebait. I agree that there are far too many people who talk a lot of shit when they don''t know what they're doing (me, for example) but when you call out people who actually do know what they're doing, then you just make yourself look stupid.

pwnd :D
 
Wow...very drawn out post to try and discredit Eli.

I also never recall Eli referring to himself as an expert but then again I'm not in love with him like you are. :p
 
There has to be someone who agrees with me..

My post wasn't directed specifically against him, but against all pseudo experts. I was using him as an example, but there are many more.
 
rodger, if you consider eli a pesudo expert what do you expect to be an expert? what credentials do YOU, rodger, have to even define what an expert is?
 
Jon, for example, is a real expert. I have read his posts on sitepoint years ago before he stopped posting and he rarely misspeaks. In addition, all the money he makes is thorugh actual affiliate marketing and not by selling a system intended to do affiliate marketing. Other real experts are shoemoeny, tyler cruz, john chow, and many others.
 
Nobody disagreed saying that there are pseudo experts out there. As long as their information is helpful -who cares. Nobody says that you have to do THE SAME they do. Just take the information you need and that´s it. If their information is wrong...well,i guess there is always somebody that will find out.
 
well if hes a pesudo expert what do you expect to be an expert? what credentials do YOU have to even define what an expert is?
I agree with you there but I don't agree with you on your use of Eli as an analogy. I've read through is blog and have found ideas there about SEO that I haven't thought of or seen written about anywhere else that were pretty sweet.
 
I agree with you there but I don't agree with you on your use of Eli as an analogy. I've read through is blog and have found ideas there about SEO that I haven't thought of or seen written about anywhere else that were pretty sweet.

gah. why was my original post so hard to understand? reread my post, i wasnt saying eli wasnt anything but an expert ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.