Some people suck at browsing blogs, forums, other sites and then putting together a plan in their head. These (stomper) guys offer a step-by-step system with MANY resources in one place and also offer one-on-one support.
There system may not be revolutionary it may not be new but it sure has great information (from what I've heard and read about them, I'm not a member).
These guys found a niche and filled a need thus in my eyes are not only respected SEO's but also marketers.
Not everyone who runs a store(mostly their target) or a website is a master SEO, self taught profesional or even has time to browse and learn slowly. These guys cator to those who want to take their store/site to the *next* level without having to do all the legwork and research themselves.
A lot of webmasters on these *webmaster* forums forget that there are new people who have a great grasp on business and their company but when it comes to the web it's greek to them. Not everyone understands google adwords, msn adcenter, or even on page optimization.
So, in the end no matter how 'simple' or expensive this system is these guys have found a niche are exploiting the market and making an assload of money doing it. Can anyone blame them? Hell no.