[SEO is dead] Top City SEO rankings case study+ Results from last thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

stevejones003

Active member
Sep 21, 2011
2,197
1
38
Rating - 100%
160   0   1
If you have already read the case study in last thread, skip the initial part. Results from last thread (many upgraded to recurring packages) will be in next bump.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Before we go to the case-study,let me provide a short overview of recent dynamics of SEO world so that we are on the same page.:338:

SEO is dead! But industry veterans say people have been screaming so for years. So,the panic is nothing new. So,where is the truth? Is there any tectonic change this time?

wLifDvl.jpg


Though Penguin/Panda Algo has made life little(?) difficult,there have been always such challenges, what has radically changed is "user behavior" (eg mobile,social media,marketplace,platform-play,discovery,native ads). Hence, a lot of people do not make purchases after searching in Google anymore. People discover stuff via platforms(amazon,YT,Pinterest etc) and read real reviews before making purchases.

These kinds of changes are affecting everyone in the industry be it a small affiliate marketer or top 500 Forbes company. Power is shifting towards consumers or existing players with strong network effect.

So,the key takeaways are

1)Observe how consumers are making the decisions in your industry and adapt. If customers in your industry are searching in Amazon,Youtube or app store,try to jam search results there too. There is no point in building a standalone website and spending $300 for SEO and ending up at page 4 forever then concluding "SEO is dead". Have multi-channel traffic sources whenever possible. Mixing SEO with retargetting via Facebook/PPC can do wonders!

2)The strategy of ranking the site with only pure spam for big keywords,when you have big brands with optimized pages in top 5 is almost dead ,unless you have very deep pockets or you are a hacker. Note that this is not applicable for big keywords,where spammers or small businesses dominate. This means pick your battle(keywords) wisely.



Ok. Enough of BS! I know most of the people are beginners here and I will not be surprised if above stuff does not make much sense to you. Now let's come to "how I can make money" from your budget of 1734$!

There is still a lot of money in SEO in the following industries even now . I would back up each with case studies in coming months.

  • Local SEO (Both lead gen and local client SEO)
  • Affiliate SEO via Youtube (Product release/review etc)
  • SEO in new industry/trends (eg Marijuana)

Case Study ( Top 7 USA City name+ SEO keyword)

I would cover Local SEO part in the following case study. Ranking for top city+SEO keywords is almost a decent gold standard to test any new link building strategy .

I generally deal with SEO resellers rather than clients directly. So,I had never tried ranking my own sites for big city keywords myself though I have ranked it for others.

I picked up this "city+SEO" keyword just to check how long does it take to rank tough local terms and wanted to test one strategy with citations. It started around the same time I started offering service in last thread.

Link Building Strategy

Thesis: "Google detects unnatural link pattern by detecting patterns in anchors and traffic of linking sites. Still,it is a sucker for exact match anchors and powerful links. Niche links help to look natural in eyes of Google".( It was mostly based on my own experience in ranking/observing 100+ sites . Only thing that has changed recently is weight age of exact match of anchors with respect to partial match anchors.)

Backlinking and Anchors

We need exact match anchors to rank and at the same time,it also triggers the unnatural warning when not done judiciously. So,I will save the exact match anchors for my best links and use generic and long tails for average links.

Week-1)

Booked a partial match domain. SEOcityname+xx.COM as made the website live. Check the #1 ranking site for keyword density and got my sales pitch written on the similar line.

W2)Published 4 how-to blog posts(400-700 words linking to leading SEO and city-specific sites) about local SEO and got a basic Youtube video done.

W3)
  • Established Fb,Twitter,Pinterest ,Youtube , Crunchbase,G+ pages and published several posts/images interlinking those. Got my VA to participate in the niche specific discussion of these social platforms. Did light social signals to money site blogposts. Spent $50 for genuine local FB likes(It was just to develop audience rather than SEO)
  • G+ Business name has keyword in it. This works like dope though looks bit spammy! Asked my old clients to put reviews on G+ page. Just made sure 2 reviews are from that city IP.

W4-6)

  • 50 citations done and pointed 400 PBN posts links to these. Dripped for 4 weeks.
  • Domain Authority stacking,DAS using 50+ foundations links (mix of web2.0,blogs,forms,editorial, G news sites etc interlinked followed by (Mix of dofollow and nofollow links/citations.). drip of 3600 tier 2 PBN links for 8 weeks.
  • Got 30+ niche specific discussion links from forums,Reddit etc and blogs done. Dripped 4 weeks.
  • Dropped 5 exact matches from my DA40+ properties. 3 of these were niche specific.

W6-16)
  • Dripped 25 sticky PBN posts in my own local niche network (where most OBLs are about US city contractors) over 10 weeks.
  • Around 9-10th week,main keywords trickled to top 3-7 and I started getting calls 3-4 calls/week. Keywords were still bouncing between top 3-6 to page 5-6 in alternate days.
  • I made the new design live which caused dropped in ranking for 2 weeks and came back after I made few tweaks.
Keyword selection

I picked up top 10 city rather than top 2-3 so that I have a realistic chance of #1-3 within a year. I needed a city where local map pack is triggered more often.

Keyword progress
3c364b2057b14cf8a9bf451aab154b7f.png


Keyword Volume

4bc5677d62124dfd841c0c0c7b4713dd.png

*MSM underreporting volume for 2 of 4 kws. But total USA search volume for cityname+seo and seo+city/company/services name is around 1.5-1.8K+


Overall,after 6 months of link building campaign, 2 keywords stabilized in #1-2 and other 2 at #3-4. It gets me around 5-10 calls/leads/week;which is below my expectation but I am yet to hit #1 for the most searched keywords. I will give it few more weeks before doing next link building campaign.

And yes,I am at #1-2 for most G maps search but depending on locations it is lower. Since,I do NOT have 5+ reviews yet,the stars are not showing which may be causing less CTR. I will get that done soon.

From around 50+ leads/calls,8+ have converted yet and which is worth around 10k/mo revenue wise.

So,what is the takeaway?

It is still possible to rank for decent good keywords within 4-6 months (at least in the local niche). Even after 2014-15 clean-up and panic,you may find some big local keywords easier than they were in 2012! Just that you need to wait in terms of months NOT 3-4 weeks as it used to be in 2012-14.


So,what is on offer?

Well,keep an eye for next bump. If you have questions,PM/email me or old members can always ping me on Skype.
 


ilg5NvF.jpg


From the last year's thread,I had around 33% customers who continued for more than 6 months and got good results (top 1-5 for big keywords). Rest of the people either got average-good results (ie page 1 but not top 3-5 or nowhere to page 2) but did not continue for more than 3 months either due to lack of budget/patience/lack of full report or simply wanted to keep all the client money! Around 10-20% were failures either due to overoptimized anchors or just canceling within 2 months.

Doing heavy the link building in 1-1.5 month can jeopardize a link profile of a website and apart from that there is a lag of 1-3 months in results for new or low trust websites.

So,I have split the link building campaigns to 2 parts so you can first buy one-time package and wait for 2-3 months to see where keywords settle.

Then depending on your confidence and budget; you can either buy monthly rental package or continue doing window shopping yourself.

Note that typically, all moderate to good keywords need high quality real/semi-real site link rentals for optimal rankings.

1)Foundations+Booster Links (One time fees)

2)Sticky posts and Rental Links (Monthly)

So,most of you can start with 1 and wait for 2-3 months for results to settle and then either sign-up for monthly package or keep doing your own window shopping according to prescribed anchor %(applicable for new projects).

So,what all you get in Foundation and Booster Link packages

It is suitable for websites where you have NOT done heavy link building campaign already. If you have already over-optimized anchors or something,it may NOT help much.

What is there in Foundation+Booster Package?

One thing that stands out in this service is it is NOT catch all "same for all" package. If you are in a niche,where it is impossible to get niche specific manual blogposts/comments,I would do generic comments etc or what % anchors used depends on your existing profile+whether your domain is EMD/PMD+what is working well.


Depending on the competition,I will decide how many citations need to be done at what. Not generic 50 or 100/200 citations,thereby triggering over optimization penalty.

Overall,I will use my judgment to adjust the composition of package and anchors,quanity of signals,citations though 75-80% stuff would remain same.

Here is the list of type of links and amount of links in brackets

Standard Package (One time payment)

Social Buzz,Brand and Trust Links (100+ signals,10+ links)

Google News DA50+ website Link (1 do-follow link)

Citations if local website(50+, 1000+ tier 2 PBN links)

Niche Manual Blog comments/forum posts/social media links (25+ links)

Domain Authority Stacking via mini sites/YT video/web2.0/Real website posts interlinking+ tier 2 PBN(40+ links+2000+ tier 2 PBN links)

High-quality 500-700+ words content,well maintained avg DA20+ PBN posts( 20+ links)

Results
9410f13ee7164c859d25a5636adbf94e.png

84d98bbc78264e868afa74e5d5efafd3.png

35ff1e34da2742de94b678ebb4a4718e.png

e782afc754034b88bb0ab8261868c7a1.png


Reviews
e7a568e9edb745539d94d643aa940abf.png

30de969867414977bbd4c25d09bf38f0.png


Standard $499 (Buy Now)


--------------------------------------------------------------------

Light $300 (Buy Now)

It is around 50% of Standard Package - Suitable for very low comp kws



--------------------------------

TAT
All links are dripped for 6-8 weeks.You will get the partial link report at the end of 6th week.


---------------------------------------------------

Skype: stevejones003
Email: stevejones003 AT AOL DOT COM
 
I have been working with Steve for quite some time now. And when he opened this thread a couple months ago I signed up for this service. Have had outstanding results. Nice to have a go to guy for SEO. You work on selling and he works on ranking
 
What forum links do you use?
And it is very hard to rank for highly competitive keywords having high search volume for new site. What is the solution?

Depends on niche and stage of your website.

"High comp kw with high search volume". Unless you have some unique angle and/or budget,it does not sound like a good business strategy to focus on those kws with a new site.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.