New Web App I Built: What do you think of it?

Put user login and explanation in the middle wide rectangle 1000x300px, under it list those apps with like 250x100px boxes each with 3 in a row so that it's instantly obvious there are tons of apps, right now all I can see is codepad and google webmaster tools and I have no idea what it does

Edit: here's how I'd change your layout

ajXy1.jpg

Thanks Jose,

This is very helpful. I'll take a stab at mimicking this layout you've wire-framed here! Hopefully this will help significantly in addressing the intuitiveness issues.
 


I believe it's the OP himself who built it. How is he going to fire himself?

Yeah I don't really see the point in firing myself. I don't cost myself anything. Plus, the architecture is actually pretty solid. It's also responsive and quite fast: Archived Performance Report for: http://whattouse.com/ | GTmetrix - There's relatively little I could do to optimize it any further. I agree that the UI and intuitiveness needs a lot of work though. If I fire myself it won't get any better though.
 
Real classy having a Google custom search box. Super duper massive fail.
I agree completely. I'm not seeing any good options using Drupal's core search or any of the major search modules that support searching Content, Taxonomy and Users all simultaneously; however, so this is my lazy temporary solution.

Do you have any recommendations?
 
The idea is really good. Trash your current site and hand over the design to someone that knows how to do it.
Thus far I have put all my energy into the underlying functionality/architecture. The design is by far the easiest part to change. It's currently in it's "minimum viable product" stage. I'm happy that a lot of people like the idea, now that I have this feedback I'll dedicate more energy to the design and UI components.
 
User login box taking up 50% of the screen real estate while I browse is pretty annoying.

Real-Time Web Analytics | What To Use - that page doesn't really get me any closer to using one product over another. I.E. what's the value of that page? Now if it said 42 people use APP1, 18 people use APP2 and lets me click through to reviews now there's value.
Couldn't agree more. The hardest part is growing users. Sounds like I need to fix the UI then get serious about promotion. I wanted to do a full Facebook integration, but apparently you need an SSL cert these days for that so I'm holding off on that for now. Plus Facebook updates/breaks their API all the time and I don't really have the time to keep up with that mess right now.
 
The UI is bad, very bad. I can't understand what to do. You need to add the follow pages:

1) About Us
2) How It Works
3) Contact Us
4) FAQ section (with actual FAQs)

-CCarter
Will do. It's almost as if I need to add "What To Use" as a Tool and make sure the Tool page explains how to use it properly =)

What do you think of the domain name? I was pretty shocked it was available.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pretty cool idea, needs some work. But you could even start paid inclusions to monetize.
It would definitely be exceptionally targeted traffic, but I won't be worrying about that for quite some time.

What I want it to do is:

1) Help me find out about tools I should be using, but am completely unaware of that my friends or others with aligned interests are using but didn't think to tell me about.

2) Utilize tasks as an effective search query when I'm actively looking for something to help me accomplish a task most efficiently/effectively.

I truly built it out of my own desire for these things which is the only reason I've been able to keep motivated. In my opinion some of the best web apps serve the needs of the creators themselves.

It definitely has a LOOOOONG way to go though.
 
The idea is good. I might actually visit this website myself.

The design however is weak. I would follow grazies template. Its just plain sensible. I wouldn't give up on the project though because I see value in it from a customers/visitors standpoint. Also, get optimzely or VWO. Don't just start changing things blind.
Precisely why I built it, recommendations like this =)
 
I have a 160 iq. I'm looking at this site, and realizing what it must feel like to be a normal person going through life.

I'm. So. Fucking. Confused.

Maybe the idea (whatever it is) is good. However the UI/UX is so bad I got lost and pushed my desk over cursing in frustration.

2/10 corners too pointy.


Edit:

Read the OP description.

Idea is fair enough. Execution is ungodly bad. And calling it a web app is a bit of a stretch as it doesn't -do- anything.
Fair, I'll do my best to change your mind on this.
 
привет;1852431 said:
hey check out this site for some ideas.

same idea, but well done.

AlternativeTo - Alternatives To The Applications You Want To Replace
I'm aware of it. Also, ironically enough discovered bestvendor.com (even more similar: What To Use Reviews & Best Uses, Productivity Software, Apps & Tools - BestVendor.com) while I was submitting it to web app directories for some exposure to garner feedback.

I am not planning to make WTU restrictive to business-oriented apps, nor am I planning to solve the ability for people to find alternatives to existing software. I just want to know about great new tools my friends are using and I want to discover people who share similar interests and find out what tools they're using. I want a search engine that handles task-based queries well. I also want to be able to adjust the site at will to better suit my needs. This is a side project, a hobby. I'm in it for the experience because I truly enjoy the work and I'm learning a lot along the way. If I only lose money on it I would be content as long as I get it to serve its original intended purpose at some point in the journey.
 
I agree completely. I'm not seeing any good options using Drupal's core search or any of the major search modules that support searching Content, Taxonomy and Users all simultaneously; however, so this is my lazy temporary solution.

Do you have any recommendations?

I suspect you have no programming background; which explains your epic fail here. Drupal is a CMS. Content Management System. I repeat. Content Management System. It's not for you to make a web-app upon, though it's possible; it would be a pain in the ass, why would you want to make your life difficult? It's like getting your ass raped by 10" black cock. Drupal search module is to search its own shit, it's not designed to automatically figure how to search your web app data.

To build a web-app, you shouldn't, or rather, cannot base it on Wordpress or Drupal, or any kind of CMS/blogging platforms. Anyone who says the otherwise is very likely fucking stupid piece of shit.
 
There used to be a lot of these "similar" or "alternative" sites on Google index. Now most of them don't even make the first page. Only a few surviving ones like alternativeto.net and similarsitesearch.com.

Now these kind of sites are easy to build because you just need to scrape them from others and extract the data. Having said that you'd need programming skill to do this semi-automatically which the OP doesn't have.

привет;1852431 said:
hey check out this site for some ideas.

same idea, but well done.

AlternativeTo - Alternatives To The Applications You Want To Replace
 
I gave him the right direction. He already started on the wrong path. Does that not count as recommendation?

привет;1852454 said:
Why are you shitting all over him he said he's a noob to this. He's building something and he asked for your RECOMMENDATIONS, not to cuss him out.
 
I suspect you have no programming background; which explains your epic fail here. Drupal is a CMS. Content Management System. I repeat. Content Management System. It's not for you to make a web-app upon, though it's possible; it would be a pain in the ass, why would you want to make your life difficult? It's like getting your ass raped by 10" black cock. Drupal search module is to search its own shit, it's not designed to automatically figure how to search your web app data.

To build a web-app, you shouldn't, or rather, cannot base it on Wordpress or Drupal, or any kind of CMS/blogging platforms. Anyone who says the otherwise is very likely fucking stupid piece of shit.
I do not consider myself to be a developer. Even if I did and you understood all the functionality that's built into the site behind-the-scenes there is no way I could have put this together in a reasonable time frame going the custom route. I have spoken to a very senior developer about the project and he agrees that this was the right approach at this time. As I've said it is a Minimal Viable Product. If it grows legs and I see real potential in it I may rebuild it from scratch or have someone else do just that. I actually started it initially on the CodeIgniter framework, but decided to switch it up so I could actually make some progress on it in my free time. I am confident that I will find a good search solution or I will customize the native one to meet my need when the time is right.

I understand that you would not use Drupal, but for me it makes my life easier and so I will continue to do so until it is no longer an option, but thus far it has been a spectacular option for me and I don't see that changing anytime soon. Open Atrium is a perfect example of a full-blown web app built on Drupal as its framework.

You definitely can build a web app in Drupal, whether you should or not depends upon a wide array of circumstances. Drupal is an extremely versatile form of a CMS. WordPress isn't, nor is Joomla. Drupal is really in its own category. I know because I have extensive experience w/ all three of them.

Ben Buckman summarizes it very well:

"-The differences between frameworks and robust CMSs are not well defined, and Drupal straddles the line between them.
-The test of whether a toolkit is a framework is whether the following question yields an affirmative answer: “Can I use this toolkit to build a given application?” Drupal clearly does.
-The exclusion reflects a kind of coder-purist snobbery ("it's not a framework if you build any of it in a UI") and lack of knowledge about Drupal's underlying code framework."

In any case, chill the fuck out man!
 
The idea is good. I might actually visit this website myself.

The design however is weak. I would follow grazies template. Its just plain sensible. I wouldn't give up on the project though because I see value in it from a customers/visitors standpoint. Also, get optimzely or VWO. Don't just start changing things blind.
I added Optimizely to WTU, thanks for the recommendation! I had heard about this, but had not actually ever checked it out before until now. Please forgive me, but what is VWO? I've probably heard of it, but don't recognize it by acronym alone yet.
 
To build a web-app, you shouldn't, or rather, cannot base it on Wordpress or Drupal, or any kind of CMS/blogging platforms. Anyone who says the otherwise is very likely fucking stupid piece of shit.

Call it what you may, but I built a app for a client that is raking in the dough, runs like a fucking dream, and is popular as hell. And no one besides myself and the startup that owns it knows it was based on WordPress.