REIMktg said:
Once again, the Christianity I find, is amazingly off target. There's is nothing on "finding your way to heaven" with regard to burial in the Bible.
It's not about "finding your way to heaven", it's about having a body here for the rapture and resurrection. You get a new body, but like anything, common thought gets skewed if you aren't literate enough to read the Word first-hand.
You have to understand, the message got passed down by word-of-mouth for thousands of years or written down and read to them by someone else. While the base of the message didn't change, people's perceptions of its meaning did, and if those hearing the message didn't know how to read, how could they verify what they were being told? It wasn't really until King James that the common people were able to read for themselves the message and Word of God.
I follow your logic to this point. But the argument is relating to LukeP's modern day Pastor's interpretation and nowhere in modern day theologically sound Christian doctrine is this found. LukeP either misunderstood the message or his Pastor is off base. Either could be true. As pointed out in earlier threads, much of the Bible itself is letters to churches of the day that were not sticking to Doctrine. Jesus came also to point out the Jews and their twisting of Doctrine. The Book of Revelation has chapters referring to the ways in which future churches would deviate from doctrine.
People want to read the Bible to suit what they want to hear, not what it says. I pointed out earlier when someone said this guy "Hagee" was representative of Christianity. No he is not, he is representative of preaching false doctrine.
So anyway, as far as Cremation and Burial goes, it was believed that your soul would be destroyed by fire if burned. So, anything unclean, like a decomposing body, witchcraft, etc. was burned to prevent them from tainting us and God in the future.
Genesis 38:24: Judah initially ordered his pregnant daughter-in-law to be burned to death because she was guilty of prostitution. This action would have caused the death of the woman and her twin fetuses.
Exodus 32:20: Moses destroyed the golden calf by burning it.
Leviticus 20:14: If a man marries both a woman and her mother, then all three "must be burned in the fire" (NIV). The passage is ambiguous: it is not known whether they would be burned alive, or would be stoned to death first, and their bodies burned later.
Leviticus 21:9: If the daughter of a priest becomes a prostitute, then she "must be burned in the fire."
Acts 19:19: Sorcerers who were converted to Christianity brought their scrolls out to be burned.
Revelation 20:15: The fate of those whose names were not written in the Book of Life is to be thrown into the lake of fire. (NIV)
So, based on that logic, if anything unclean is burned and thought to be destroyed forever - your Soul could be as well and not come back with a new body if cremated. I could be wrong, but that's how I've perceived the Word when reading those passages dealing with burning and cremation when discussing those actions.
None of the above mention redemption or of thwarting reincarnation. The burning above is the way they chose to destroy something. Back then, they had no other way to destroy things. The death sentence was for many things, though scholars have debated the use of the words in some of those verses that could also mean "branding". The Sorcerers, it was just they way to permanently destroy their scrolls. Even in the Revelation quote, the use of "lake of fire" is hotly debated amongst Theologians.
Either way, you should not conclude that the fire in any of the verses above somehow purified anything. The fire destroyed it. I do not see anywhere in the quoted verses that a soul could come back. You mentioned something unclean being burned and not coming back, that is correct. Those punished above with death, if they were, would not be coming back. They were not being redeemed, they were removed.
However, cremation is hardly mentioned at all in the New Testament. So, if you believe in Jesus, you can probably have a safe bet that you'll be okay if you get cremated and lived a good life. After all, it'd suck to be burned in a house fire and be screwed for eternity.
Right. There is nothing wrong with cremation.
REIMktg said:
There is no implication of a soul wandering the earth in the Bible. I suppose your preacher should have read the Bible more.
Now this is something that is mentioned a fair bit in the Bible. The most direct passage comes on Jesus' resurrection when he makes it clear that he was "not a ghost", which implies that since he is not one, they obviously exist.
Jesus' disciples were in a boat on the Sea of Galilee, but he was not with them. Matthew tells us what happened:
Shortly before dawn Jesus went out to them, walking on the lake. When the disciples saw him walking on the lake, they were terrified. "It's a ghost," they said, and cried out in fear. But Jesus immediately said to them: "Take courage! It is I. Don't be afraid."(Matthew 14:25-27, NIV)
After his resurrection, Jesus appeared to his disciples. Again they were terrified:
They were startled and frightened, thinking they saw a ghost. He said to them, "Why are you troubled, and why do doubts rise in your minds? Look at my hands and my feet. It is I myself! Touch me and see; a ghost does not have flesh and bones, as you see I have." (Luke 24:37-39, NIV)
The Disciples were always getting things wrong throughout the Bible. They thought there were Ghosts. The passages where they thought Jesus to be a Ghost, that is because they thought Ghosts exist. Your last verse quoted is Jesus telling them he is not a Ghost. He is not implying there are Ghosts. For example, if I startled someone after they thought I was dead and they were scared, not understanding that I was not dead, I too may say, "Look, touch my hands, look at me, feel me, do Ghosts have substance? I am real." I am tapping into their perception of what a Ghost would be, not agreeing that their are ghosts.
With that said the Bible does not allow for Ghosts of ancestors and people to be present. Though a person can come back or even be summoned by a Sorcerer, but not as a Ghost. As either a real person as in the case of Lazarus or vision as was the case with Samuel. But the Bible does make it clear that their are Angels, Demons, Spirits etc around us all of the time. It is these extradimensional beings that could pose as a Ghost or pose as a Person or work with Sorcerers etc. So there are no "Ghosts" of relatives with souls wandering around, but there are Spirit beings, according to the Bible.