Once the anonymity feature of bitcoins gets clamped down on by the gov't, bitcoins will be doomed.
You just don't get the tech then if you can state this.
First of all, all nodes see all transactions. Check this out:
Bitcoin Monitor
So for people who allow others to see their addresses, it is certainly not anonymous. It's absolutely transparent if you connect yourself to the address in question.
But if you're trying to hide something, you can be absolutely positive that it's untraceable by only using that address one time for one thing only... Never posting it where it can be seen anywhere... Wallets let you generate new addresses per every single transaction if you'd like... The whole concept of
instawallet is based upon this fact.
At that point, someone would have to have direct access to your computer &/or ISP activity (Keylogger?) to connect you to an address. Surely you can be smart and use a clean computer through a VPN though, right?
No government or spy or god for that matter could "remove" the anonymity from your wallet if you knew how to use it properly. Bitcoin can be exactly as safe and anonymous as you need it to be... And like facebook, it can expose to much if your IQ is close to your hat size.
1. If someone asked you to buy "coin" that existed only in cyberspace and was backed by nothing but a mathematical equation, would you think they were sane?
Just like the first time this happened to me, I'd seek to learn more before trusting anyone.
(BTW,the regression theorem fully explains why unbacked paper money today can have value, just in case LukeP is reading.)
But ultimately that value is undesirable, because it's force against you, not commodity that you own.
Honestly, I don't see how bitcoin violates the theorem. You're just trying to make me yawn again.
2. If the anonymity feature of bitcoins disappeared, do you think that would devastate them?
Since it's anonymity exists in a range of states now, I'd expect a range of responses from whatever the government tries to do.
I could see them tapping the ISPs to try to tie ppl to their addresses, eventually. What this is going to do, and yes I'm very sure of this, is quadruple the VPN business sector the day the news breaks, and then create a whole new, profitable market of ISPs that won't cooperate with the man... Likely in North Korea.
If the fed/potus/treasury gets serious about btc because it's eaten away a whole percent or more of the world economy, then I'd think they wouldn't fuck around with anonymity, and instead pass a law against merchants accepting it, then go directly for the 51% attack.
That's the only thing I fear, honestly. Because I'm informed.
Even if the gov't can't completely shut down bitcoin, it will primarily be used for illegal transactions... Most or all of their value is derived from money laundering.
Why do you think this?
Do you think the majority of the $500 Million in bitcoin right now was illegal transactions?
In a poll of over 500 bitcoin users, the majority are libertarians who buy to hoard or spend at bitcoin vendors, who believe much like you but with more optimism. They usually state that they use bitcoin b/c they want this new economy to exist.
I used to mine ore and iron in Runescape many years ago. At one point I purchased an auto-miner to do it for me. They detected it and banned me, which led to me quitting the game. What are we mining here and can I get banned again?
1. You are mining a digital unit of currency that is NOT controlled by a central authority like runescape's was.
2. There is no one to "ban" you but the FED. When they try they will find it exceedingly difficult, because the designer was a genius and this system really only has one weakness: They'd need more computing power than god.