Love your wife. But be a fucking MAN. Grow some balls and take charge. From my experience women will respect you more and actually like when you man up.
1. Calling the GP's could backfire as your wife will tell you that you betrayed her and violated her trust.
2. Maybe your wife is uncomfortable with her relatives or maybe a single relative and wants/needs you there for support. Knowing you "will be there" is important - women need the security. - for this you could have your bro go to the reunion and watch it in a room.
One thing is certain - from a male perspective she is being unreasonable. I have found that when my wife seems unreasonable it is because there is more to the situation than I think.
You need to find out the underlying issue:
1. Trust
2. your "being there"
3. security
4. doing something "for her" which is an offshoot of needing more security in the marriage
There is some reason she needs you there - find out, then address the issue. Then you will be able to go to your brothers, or have him come over. There are probably other relatives that will want to watch the fight too.
If you cannot figure out how to communicate and uncover unsaid issues, then you are in store for a lot of marital problems.
In the end, your wife needs to know she comes first. Not your family. That may be one of the underlying issues - if her family rarely gets together - does she feel it is always "your family"?
I used to think like this, but my wife got really pissed off with me always looking for "underlying issues". The truth is, she's just stubborn for no reason at all other than she's tired or something sometimes.
Now I just let her be right and work around her, without worrying too much about what the issues might be, and things are much better.
But then, I guess everyone's different.
I thought about that....but if she got on here, she'd probably start browsing the site, and tell me I could never access it again (due to all the boobs).
Whoever organized their respective thing first and let the other one know about it is "right". But when it comes to wives it pays very little to be right.
Being right and being married are two incompatible things a lot of the time.
The thread title reads: "Solve this disagreement between the wife and I, who's right?"
It should be: "Solve this disagreement between me and the wife; who's right?"
Since this question was asked with wrong grammar, it is invalid and you fail.
The wife wins.
PS: She's being unreasonable.
You're approaching this all wrong. She's not a guy. Women don't respond to rational arguments in emotional situations.
I have a wife who is possible the most rational person you could meet at work, but when shit like this crops up, she's a fucking fruitloop.
Luckily, this fact makes them remarkably easy to outmaneuvre, if you just think a few steps ahead. Here's how I'd run it:
Call up her Grandparents, tell 'em how much you are looking forward to the reunion, and then explain the brother situation. Ask if it's OK, because you didn't want to offend them, but it would mean a lot to him.
They will (ofc) say yes. You can tell your wife then that you didn't want to upset her GPs, so you called them to check, and they insisted that see your brother.
Having done that, you've now placed your wife in an impossible situation.
She can either let you go see your brother.
Or she can carry on insisting, and have to explain to GPs why she wouldn't let you see your brother, and look like a shrew at the reunion.
Now, the important thing here is how you break this to your wife.
DO NOT FRAME IT IN AS I WAS RIGHT AND YOU WERE WRONG.
The key with women is to let them feel that they're right, whilst doing whatever the fuck you want with your life.
So you say "You know, you were right honey, I was being thoughtless about this."
(pause).
"So I called up you GPs to check that it was ok, because I really wouldn't want to upset them or your family. And they insisted that I go."
Try not to smirk when you do this as it will ruin the whole effort.
Right - mine is just the opposite.
But I do not have to search for the issues any longer I already know them. But my wife is completely reasonable and not stubborn. In the above situation I would take her to the reunion, make certain everything was cool, kiss her on the cheek and say - I will be back later I am going to my brothers, and be gone. No issues.
But the problem is as you stated,
Everyone is different. ---- for all OP knows his wife is always hit on by an uncle or worse by some other relative. There are a lot of skeletons at family reunions.
This right here along with your initial post tells me that you're a gigantic pussy that bows down to whatever your wife says/wants.I thought about that....but if she got on here, she'd probably start browsing the site, and tell me I could never access it again (due to all the boobs).