It would be a fun thought experiment. Building a system of law from the ground up - sans democracy, sans government - makes 99% of our current laws seem silly.
This is essentially what is going down (not the experiment part) with cypherpunkery & specifically
Lex Cryptographia today. We live in extremely exciting times.
So you either go with some Form of democracy or have a bloody struggle for power. Not too many novelty options out there.
Well, there's a bunch of times and places where anarchy thrived on some level; Medieval Ireland was a particularly long-standing anarchy, some say thousands of years without an irish king, just thousands of small, peaceful compounds or micro-serfdoms.
That's not good enough for me of course, but today we're finally at a point where some new options can start working, so I'm working towards seeing those happen.
Let's say I've read some of that material. Or something similar. I've read locke. You need to explain why something like your ancap dreams don't exist in the present. Would it not be correct to assume that such societies would be easily dismantled By foreign military Invasion?
There are many books spelling out exactly why this couldn't happen; Bob Murphy's Chaos Theory and Stephan Molyneux's
Practical Anarchy are both freely available and do a good job explaining this.
Get to the interesting stuff. It's difficult to have such thought experiments that take place in a utopia bubble. I don't care for democracy any more than you do, but wishful thinking won't get you something that differs in major ways from prehistoric, ancient, medieval, renaissance or modern civilizations.
You can't change someones' religion by burning down their church.
Statism is a religion. That means that there is no way whatsoever to use military force to change to anarchy or even just hold it there... Anarchy, the lack of statism, is something that can only be achieved through widespread, strong-majority choice.
People have to come to anarchy first before it can be realized. For hundreds of years now the best thinkers have always concluded that this means we must convert everyone through 1-on-1 dialog such as we anarchists are attempting to do with you on this thread now.
Luckily, today we have a new option; Cryptoanarchy will deliver anarchy to people without them even realizing it; They'll embrace free services like bittorrent and money like Bitcoin because of the obvious benefits it brings them, and more and more of these services will appear where government services used to exist until one day even the most obtuse crackwhore will look around and say,
"Hey, if I'm getting all this good shit for free, what the fuck am I still paying taxes for?"
This wasn't an option until the day someone realized that P2P networks could completely evade government takedown. It should be obvious to anyone paying attention that the answer to all our problems is to simply remake everything on a P2P network.
I wonder when people are going to actually stand up for themselves and create a real "police" force made up entirely of civilian volunteers.
Here's a basic cryptoanarchists' solution for this problem: